I started this post in response to a comment to a post below, and my response sort of grew and I think merits an entry on its own. That comment, meantime, seems to have disappeared - we've just started this group blog thing; bear with us - but the comment noted two assumptions made about bankruptcy. I quote:
1. People in bankruptcy feel bad about not being able to pay their debt
2. People in bankruptcy originally had every intention to pay back the loans they took
And those assumptions are absolutely correct. I'm attorney of record in, last I checked, about 1,600 cases, and my clients have always approached bankruptcy with the seriousness it deserves. Don't just take my word for it, though:
For one, a debtor doesn't get to take debt out knowing that they're going to file a bankruptcy. If it smells like that's taken place, their creditors have rights. A creditor can attempt to have their debt declared nondischargable and collect attorneys' fees for so doing. It's exceedingly rare that such actions are even brought, and substantially more rare that they're adjudicated in the creditor's favor. It happens, but not with any sort of regularity. Off the cuff, I'd guess less than 0.5% of debtors have one creditor who even attempts such an action (let alone wins), though I haven't crunched the numbers myself.
But so, is it that bankrupt people are innocently negligent of the basics of personal finance? Resoundingly, overwhelmingly, no. The personal finance skills of the bankrupt are fine, and citations as to why are easy to find. Hope the hyperlinks work - as said, we're still kicking the tires on this blogging deal:
1) Elisabeth Warren and her co-authors, in "The Fragile Middle Class: Americans in Debt" says that 67.5% of people who file bankruptcy report they filed because of an income interruption/job loss/downsizing. (The first chapter, including that statistic, is here, http://yalepress.yale.edu/YupBooks/pdf/0300079605.pdf?winOpen=true, though a lot of the information is a bit dated, being pre-BAPCPA.)
Debt happens to good people. Everyone knows that debt causes stress and that stress causes problems - stress damages people's health, their well-being, their relationships with their loved ones. Debt can lead to skipping meals, not heating homes enough, falling behind on rent. The recent documentary "Maxed Out" tells the stories of two families whose loved ones committed suicide because of their debt.
Bankruptcy is the government's way of saying that a person is more important than the money they owe.